Wanted – 13 November 2026
Riding on a dust storm of electric energy and powerhouse vocals, Wanted tells a tale of family folklore about two outlaw sisters who braved a world inaccessible to most of their birth in a successful endeavor to take back riches and wealth from society’s elite. Taking place in the wake of slavery, Mary Clarke (Solea Pfeiffer) and Martha Clarke (Liisi LaFontaine), who are of half Black and half white parentage, powder their faces to pass for white, then use the spaces they gain entry to to rob white people blind. They send the money back to their mother Tallulah Clarke (Jennie Harney-Fleming, in for Ledisi at this performance), who is saving up to make the healing transition from being property to owning property. Throughout the show, the sisters are watched over by a Greek chorus of their ancestors, who, in addition to guiding Mary and Martha, gave some of the best vocal performances on Broadway. The show demanded an incredibly high bar for vocal power and precision that is going to be tough to replicate when the licensing trickles down. There aren’t many who can match Melody A. Betts’s level of performance as she solos over numbers with an apparent ease absolutely at odds with the difficult, demanding vocal precision. The show is worth seeing for its closing number alone, in which Solea Pfeiffer, Liisi LaFontaine, Jennie Harney-Fleming, and Melody A Betts bring the house down with their soaring vocal solos.
The story of Wanted strives for universality in its vague, yet charming tale of risk, love, loss, and finding out what you’re really made of. It makes a highly uncommon experience— being able to pass as another race— into a relatable, fun adventure. The sisters begin inseparable, then diverge as Mary decides her personal gain and comfort are the biggest achievable victory while Martha bends towards a little bit of justice for everyone being worth losing her lover for. In the end, they bend back towards each other, their home, and the legacy in their blood. This triumphant return is what the story is really about. It’s important to take pride in who you came from; this was salient at the time when this story is set, because it was rare for Black people, especially those who were formerly enslaved, to know much about their heritage. The insistence that the Clarke sisters had a powerful circle of ancestors implies that everyone does, emphasizing the importance of being proud of who you are. It’s a tricky situation in this story because the sisters are pretending to be of heritage that they are not, but the ancestors’ acceptance of this and trust in their journey speaks volumes to how many different ways there are to do your people proud.
This inspiring show is easily accessible to audiences of all ages and backgrounds. The journey is fun and the voices are tremendous. Beowulf Boritt’s set transforms into different shapes and places, always with a healthy amount of fog and smoke to add to the illusion. Stefania Bulbarella’s video and projection design is utterly brilliant, particularly in the train scene. There were many moments with repeating patterns in projections that resolve into images, including cotton fields at poignant moments. Emilio Sosa’s costumes had to span many different worlds, and did so with a graceful spark of creativity that made everything feel raw and real. Adam Honoré’s lighting design heightened the spectacle and helped raise the stakes, while Gareth Owen’s sound design had a pulsating gyration the audience could feel in their bones. Taken together, the design team elevates the production into something sensational.
Wanted is the kind of show that might unravel under intense scrutiny. I had some questions about when specifically this was meant to be taking place, plot holes in Martha’s big plan, how Mary changed her mind so quickly, the change in how Tallulah’s sudden fortunes were viewed, and other moments that didn’t quite add up. The thing is, the show doesn’t require intense scrutiny for sincere enjoyment. The vocals are astounding, the world of the show is monumental, and the message about being proud of who you are is vitally important in today’s world. There is no such thing as a perfect production, but this one delivers all an audience could reasonably have wanted.
I attended this performance on a press pass from Rubenstein.

